[Skip to content]

Midwives magazine logo
ADVERTISEMENT
Search our Site
E-zine

E-newsletters

The latest midwifery news and events sent straight to your inbox

Subscribe here...

ADVERTISEMENT
Products
.

Saying 'no' to breastfeeding

Julie Griffiths
Julie Griffiths, guest blogger
15.27, 19 August 2010

A poll of young women finds a third would shun breastfeeding because they want to avoid saggy boobs. For some, vanity is the overriding factor when weighing up the pros and cons of breastfeeding. It seems a sad indictment of young women’s priorities when a baby’s health comes second to their looks. Or is it?

The survey of 1228 women between 18 and 25 follows the recent furore caused by model Gisele Bundchen who proclaimed there should be a law to force mothers to breastfeed their babies for at least six months.

Half of the women polled by BabyChild.org.uk would fall foul of Gisele’s law because they had no plans to breastfeed. And 32% of them said the main reason was because they did not want to ‘ruin the look of their breasts’. Half of them were afraid of their partner finding them less attractive should this happen.

Another 19% felt ‘uncomfortable’ about the thought of breastfeeding, a quarter of whom said they viewed their breasts as sexual and therefore deemed it inappropriate.

All these arguments seem feeble and bizarre when stacked against the benefits of breastfeeding. What about protecting the baby against obesity, asthma and childhood diabetes? What about helping the baby avoid ear, urine and gastro-intestinal infections?

I suspect that another benefit of breastfeeding would hold greater sway for those polled, which is that it can speed up weight loss during pregnancy.

My reason? Because the young women surveyed were childless and, at their stage of life, sexual attractiveness and looks are of great importance. They have no particular reason to know about the benefits of breastfeeding - more than three quarters of those who were against the idea believed their decision would not harm the baby’s health.

The findings of the poll would be much more worrying if they were the views of pregnant 18 to 25 year olds. But for childless young women to voice an uninformed opinion on breastfeeding is, perhaps, unsurprising.
 

COMMENTS

1. At 11.23 on 23 August 2010, disappointed wrote:

Having been a midwife for many years and a mother of two daughters I have often commented on the benefits of breastfeeding. I was very disappointed when my youngest (16) declared that if she had a baby she would not breastfeed as she didn't want ‘droopy boobs’.

‘What had given her this idea?’ I asked - the answer was she had been watching various cosmetic surgery, look 10 years younger type of TV programmes, and they had consistently accredited saggy breasts with breastfeeding a baby. Apparently increase in ones weight, loss of weight, ageing and general breast care were hardly mentioned if at all. I intend to watch these programmes to see if the production teams as well as the surgeons are all male!


2. At 12.31 on 30 August 2010, Alison Blenkinsop wrote:

This is tragic. Dr Christian Jessen of Embarrassing Bodies has stated on TV and in Closer magazine recently that breastfeeding and breast infections such as mastitis definitely cause the breasts to sag. I have written to complain, but the damage has already been done. I encourage other midwives to write to the press complaints commission about this. He has no evidence for stating such a thing, whereas there is clear evidence that lactation does not affect the subsequent shape of the breasts.



3. At 17.30 on 29 October 2010, Mary Cronk wrote:

Could Alison Blenkinsop quote the evidence to support her statement that lactation does not affect the subsequent shape of the breast? I know the evidence is out there but cannot find the ref. I would like the ref sent to the ignorant Dr Christian Jessen.

Add a comment to this blog posting

Comments are added to the bottom of blog postings. They are moderated and will not be published until approved by the Midwives team. They may be edited.

 

» Indicates required fields

Make a comment
Can we display your name on the site? »