[Skip to content]

Midwives magazine logo
Search our Site
E-zine

E-newsletters

The latest midwifery news and events sent straight to your inbox

Subscribe here...

ADVERTISEMENT
Products
.

Are healthy women to be offered c-sections?

Midwives magazine: Issue 7 :: 2011

Claims have been splashed across newspapers that all pregnant mothers are to be offered caesarean sections.

Caesarean section
There are reports that this ‘hugely expensive move’ will lead to further financial turmoil for an already cash-strapped NHS.

However, despite the allegations and rumours, there are no plans on the table to offer caesarian sections to all mothers-to-be.

The claims relate to draft guidelines set to be released by NICE in December.

These currently include the recommendation that women who have anxiety about birth be referred to health professionals with ‘expertise in perinatal mental health support’.

They say ‘if after proper counselling’ a vaginal birth is still not acceptable, the option of caesarean section ‘should still be possible’.

But there is no proposal in the document – which is still subject to change – saying women will be given the right to the procedure.

Cathy Warwick, RCM chief executive, stressed that the NICE guidelines are in draft form and that the RCM is involved in their development.

‘The RCM notes that much of the recent reporting on the draft guidelines is inaccurate,’ she said.

‘The guidelines emphasis that women asking for an elective caesarean section should be given support and information and possibly referred for expert counselling.

‘The RCM believes that the draft guidelines reflect the practice that is currently in place in most maternity units.

‘If a woman, for whatever reason, feels she is psychologically unable to face the prospect of a normal delivery then the RCM does not believe clinicians are currently denying her that option.

‘Many of the women who ask for an elective caesarean have previously had a traumatic or difficult birth.’

She added that in cases where women ask for a caesarean section for ‘purely social convenience’ the RCM does not think the procedure is appropriate.

RCOG also released a statement saying the claims that caesarean sections will be offered to all women are ‘misleading and inaccurate’.

It continued: ‘There is no proposal in the current NICE guidelines which state that women should have the automatic right to a caesarean section.’

Comments
I feel so strongly about this - I spend a lot of my time antenatally helping women, little by little, to overcome their fear of childbirth - usually successfully. TIME is what is needed, plus continuity, and the MW should be trusting birth and really listening to the woman's story. It often takes me 2 or 3 visits before I get to the bottom of it all - you cannot 'educate' a woman in 15 minutes from behind a desk.

Alison Reid (05/11/2011 07:44:54)

I am pleased that NICE has developed a draft proposal on elective C/S. I think it will highlight the very poor perinatal mental health resources available to women.

Women who have undergone an emergency C/S have very different memories of their delivery and this influences their choice of delivery for subsequent pregnancies.

On the issue of cost, how long does a C/S and immediate recovery take? I anticipate 3 hours. Compare this to the cost of home visit for stretch and sweeps up to 3-5 visits. Add induction of labout by ARM, continuous monitoring , possible use of syntocinon, analgesia 1:1 care with a success rate of 70%. How do the other 30% feel?

I would be pleased to hear other members' views.

Lesley Henage (06/11/2011 11:23:14)

It is about time that anxiety over birth and the effect of previous traumatic birth was recognised, without prejudice - by everyone. Some women have issues that cause them to be terrified of birth, or wish to avoid the effect of another birth on their emotional wellbeing - why make them feel bad for still wanting to be mothers? In a civilised society, claiming to give informed choice to women, we most definitely should support elective caesarian section for previous traumatic delivery, or anxiety surrounding birth. I love normal birth and feel in awe of the power of the human body, the human mind is also very powerful... I will leave it there!

Anon Pro-Choice (14/03/2012 17:02:20)